OSCE Special Monitoring Mission to Ukraine monitoring the movement of heavy weaponry in Eastern Ukraine; photo by OSCE SMM via Flickr (CC BY 2.0)

Zum Symposium

Between aspirations and realities

The legal framework of the OSCE in the focus


The deployment of the OSCE Special Monitoring Mission (SMM) in the wake of the Ukraine crisis illustrated once more the difficulties related to the legal status of the Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe (OSCE). Despite its name, the OSCE is not an international organization in the public international law sense and lacks international legal personality. One of the main consequences in practice is that OSCE personnel sent abroad does not have diplomatic privileges and immunities. This can hamper the effective functioning of this institution, which is with its 57 participating states from Europe, Central Asia and North America the world’s largest regional security organization. Covering a wide array of concerns relating to human, politico-military and economic-environmental topics, the mandate of this important institution exceeds purely security-related concerns. Even though the formalization of the OSCE’s institutional structure has been subject to debate since a long time, it remains an open issue until today.

These questions were at the heart of the international conference “Between Aspirations and Realities: Strengthening the Legal Framework of the OSCE” convened by Carolyn Moser, Anne Peters and Mateja Steinbrück Platise in the name of the Max-Planck-Institute for Comparative Public and International Law, bringing together international scholars and practitioners with expertise in legal, political and related fields. We are delighted to host in the two next weeks a series of contributions that were presented and discussed during the conference. Christian Tomuschat will open the symposium, critically reflecting on a possible shift to a more legalized status of the OSCE. A possible institutional duty of loyalty of the OSCE participating states, derived from customary international law, will then be explored by Cedric Ryngaert. In her contribution, Isabelle Ley unravels both the theoretical and practical complexities of the debate on the legal framework and/or status of the OSCE. She sheds light on the schizophrenic state as well as the mutually blocking intentions concerning the process of strengthening the legal foundations of the organization. Finally, Gleb Bogush spins this line of argument further. He provides valuable insights as to the intricate wider geopolitical and institutional context in which the legalization of the OSCE is discussed.

We are looking forward to thought-stimulating contributions and welcome remarks and questions!


Cite as: Raffaela Kunz, “Between Aspirations and Realities: The legal framework of the OSCE in the focus”, Völkerrechtsblog, 1 August 2016, doi: 10.17176/20180412-214817.

Raffaela Kunz

Raffaela Kunz ist Senior Research Fellow am Max-Planck-Institut für ausländisches öffentliches Recht und Völkerrecht und Co-Chefredakteurin des Völkerrechtsblog.

Profil anzeigen
Artikel drucken

Schreibe einen Kommentar

Wir freuen uns, wenn Du mit den Beiträgen auf dem Völkerrechtsblog über die Kommentarfunktion interagierst. Dies tust Du jedoch als Gast auf unserer Plattform. Bitte habe Verständnis dafür, dass Kommentare nicht sofort veröffentlicht werden, sondern von unserem Redaktionsteam überprüft werden. Dies dient dazu, dass der Völkerrechtsblog ein sicherer Ort der konstruktiven Diskussion für alle bleibt. Wir erwarten, dass Kommentare sich sachlich mit dem entsprechenden Post auseinandersetzen. Wir behalten uns jederzeit vor, hetzerische, diskriminierende oder diffamierende Kommentare sowie Spam und Kommentare ohne Bezug zu dem konkreten Artikel nicht zu veröffentlichen.

Deinen Beitrag einreichen
Wir begrüßen Beiträge zu allen Themen des Völkerrechts und des Völkerrechtsdenkens. Bitte beachte unsere Hinweise für Autor*innen und/oder Leitlinien für Rezensionen. Du kannst uns Deinen Text zusenden oder Dich mit einer Voranfrage an uns wenden:
Abonniere den Blog
Abonniere den Blog um regelmäßig über neue Beiträge informiert zu werden, indem Du Deine E-Mail-Adresse in das unten stehende Feld einträgst.