Debating "Beyond Human Rights"Symposium

Simple international rights, global constitutionalism, and scholarly methods

A rejoinder to comments on “Beyond Human Rights” – part 1

An unexpected, organized, serious, and multiple engagement with arguments put forward in a manuscript which has gained shape, has grown, was written and re-written, was shrunk, cut, re-arranged, and which haunted my nights over so many years, which was proof-read and re-read so many times (though without detecting a number of embarrassing typos) − such an engagement is surely the most precious gift any scholar can ever receive. I am …

READ MORE →

Debating "Beyond Human Rights"Symposium

Beyond Individual Criminal Responsibility?

Anne Peters’ most recent opus ‘Beyond Human Rights: The Legal Status of the Individual in International Law’ constitutes an outstanding and ground-breaking piece of scholarship that radically re-positions the individual within the grid system of international law and consistently supplements her previous work on global constitutionalism: The book hence establishes a new frame of reference for analysing the individual’s status under international law as – instead of exclusively focussing on …

READ MORE →

Debating "Beyond Human Rights"Symposium

De-constitutionalizing individual rights beyond the state?

Democracy and universality below and between human rights   

With its translation into English, Anne Peters’ “Beyond Human Rights” provokes reactions from a wider scholarly community that does not necessarily share her doctrinal methods, theoretical commitments or underlying political philosophy. Zoran Oklopic thus reads her work critically as a call for a “ius cosmopoliticum” based on “normative individualism”, as a liberal legalism which empowers the bourgeois to effectively enforce individual – read: corporate – property rights through investment arbitration but …

READ MORE →

Debating "Beyond Human Rights"Symposium

Investors’ Rights Short of Human Rights in a Constitutional Perspective

It will come as no surprise for readers familiar with Anne Peters’ reflections on the international legal system to grasp from her Jenseits der Menschenrechte that also foreign investors are vested with rights rooted in international law (257-307). This phenomenon is linked to a continuous process of internationalisation of legal relationships with host states. But indeed neither the very nature of that process nor that of their rights are well …

READ MORE →

Debating "Beyond Human Rights"Symposium

Beyond Human Rights – Beyond International Law?

There is much to admire in Anne Peters’ book, so much that after reading Jenseits der Menschenrechte, it is difficult to imagine what else can be done in this area of the law. Peters’ book represents the standard treatise in the field for the time being, ably demonstrating chapter by chapter that the individual enjoys direct legal status in international law way beyond human rights.

READ MORE →

Debating "Beyond Human Rights"Symposium

Beyond Human Rights: Beyond a Convertible Vattelian?

Anne Peters’ Beyond Human Rights: The Legal Status of the Individual in International Law is an impressive scholarly intervention, which can be read both as a standalone contribution to the debates about the position of the individual in international law, as well as a companion to Peters’ previous work on global constitutionalism and the constitutionalization of international law.

READ MORE →

Debating "Beyond Human Rights"Symposium

Beyond Human Rights

Our authors debate Anne Peters book on the individual in international law

With the first symposium after our relaunch, Völkerrechtsblog emphasizes its role as a forum for transnational legal debate – a debate that transcends jurisdictions and that connects scholars from different academic communities and parts of the world. We aim to encourage such debates with our new format, the book symposium. We invite authors to discuss important new publications from the German-speaking community in English language to make them accessible to a wider …

READ MORE →

DiscussionResponse

Das Internetgrundrecht zwischen Völkerrecht, Staatsrecht und Europarecht (III)

In Teil I habe ich gezeigt, dass das Völkerrecht den Zugang zum Internet in seinen beiden Dimensionen als Vorbedingung zur Ausübung kommunikativer Rechte schützt. In Teil II habe ich nachgewiesen, dass dem Grundgesetz ein unmittelbarer verfassungsrechtlicher Leistungsanspruch auf Gewährleistung eines menschenwürdigen Existenzminimums zu entnehmen ist. Dieser schützt in der Auslegung des BVerfG ein Recht auf Teilhabe am kommunikativen Leben, das zu den Bedingungen der Informationsgesellschaft nur durch Internetzugang gesichert werden …

READ MORE →

DiscussionResponse

Das Internetgrundrecht zwischen Völkerrecht, Staatsrecht und Europarecht (II)

In Teil I habe ich gezeigt, dass das Völkerrecht den Internetzugang in beiden Dimensionen – Zugang zum Internet (Infrastrukturdimension) und Zugang zu Internetinhalten (Inhaltsdimension) – schützt. Ein Recht auf Internetzugang (oder kürzer: ein Recht auf Internet) ist Vorbedingung der Realisierung aller anderen Menschenrechte über das Internet. Es setzt jedoch zumindest eine grundlegende staatlich garantierte Kommunikationsinfrastruktur voraus. Nationales Verfassungsrecht, Völkerrecht und auch Europarecht spielen hier ineinander.

READ MORE →

DiscussionKick-off

Das Internetgrundrecht zwischen Völkerrecht, Staatsrecht und Europarecht (I)

Die aktuellen Entwicklungen um die wachsende Anzahl von Flüchtlingen in Europa führen Debatten in nicht erwartete Richtungen. So dynamisiert die Frage, inwieweit Flüchtlingsunterkünfte mit WLAN, womöglich ‚Freifunk‘, ausgestattet werden können, die Diskussion um das Recht auf Internetzugang. Natürlich muss der Staat nicht jedem Flüchtling ein Smartphone zur Verfügung stellen. Das lässt aber das Grundrecht auf Internetzugang unberührt. Teil I des Beitrages widmet sich der völkerrechtlichen Begründung dieses Rechts, Teil II …

READ MORE →